| Table 14. Logistic Regression Analysis of Supreme Court Decisions on First Amendment Cases, 1954-1988 | |||||||
| (Only Justices Who Participated in Brandenburg) | |||||||
| Predictor | Before and After Brandenburg | Before Brandenburg Only | After Brandenburg Only | ||||
| Attitudes of Justices | -1.90 | *** | -1.49 | ** | -3.91 | *** | |
| (0.53) | (0.70) | (1.20) | |||||
| Brandenburg | -2.36 | *** | |||||
| (0.60) | |||||||
| Political Speech | -2.63 | *** | 8.49 | ||||
| (0.83) | (53.86) | ||||||
| DOCTRINE | |||||||
| Likely and Imminent Risk of Lawless Action | 1.31 | * | -7.22 | -12.59 | |||
| (0.75) | (27.34) | (336.65) | |||||
| Not an Issue | -0.39 | 0.01 | -10.92 | ||||
| (0.49) | (0.56) | (299.66) | |||||
| SETTING | |||||||
| Public forum | -0.64 | -9.17 | -6.82 | ||||
| (0.90) | (27.36) | (199.20) | |||||
| Semi-public forum | 0.77 | 1.23 | 3.69 | ||||
| (0.93) | (1.41) | (2.82) | |||||
| Not an Issue | 0.78 | 0.73 | 2.72 | ||||
| (1.02) | (1.58) | (2.24) | |||||
| GOVERNMENT | |||||||
| Federal | 0.91 | -9.95 | 2.75 | ||||
| (0.74) | (27.33) | (191.78) | |||||
| State | -0.76 | -9.92 | 12.64 | ||||
| (0.62) | (27.35) | (199.22) | |||||
| School or University | -2.62 | ** | -19.73 | [no cases] | |||
| (1.26) | (54.64) | ||||||
| No Government | 2.06 | ** | 1.94 | * | [no cases] | ||
| (0.89) | (1.02) | ||||||
| SPEAKER | |||||||
| Communist | -1.88 | ** | -9.42 | 19.79 | |||
| (0.78) | (27.32) | (107.76) | |||||
| Racial Minority | -1.99 | *** | -9.67 | -0.40 | |||
| (0.68) | (27.31) | (1.75) | |||||
| Other | -0.82 | -17.74 | 22.31 | ||||
| (0.78) | (48.41) | (107.76) | |||||
| Constant | 5.10 | *** | 18.48 | -12.58 | |||
| (1.62) | (54.63) | (373.95) | |||||
| Chi square | 76.76 | *** | 55.14 | *** | 48.48 | *** | |
| (15 d.f.) | (13 d.f.) | (12 d.f.) | |||||
| R-squared | 0.25 | 0.26 | 0.55 | ||||
| % Correctly Predicted | 80.78 | 78.05 | 92.31 | ||||
| % Reduction in Error | 35.80 | 38.99 | 58.83 | ||||
| N | 255 | 164 | 91 | ||||
| Chow Test Chi Square | 57.41*** | ||||||
| (13 d.f.) | |||||||
| * | significant at p<.10 | ||||||
| ** | significant at p<..05 | ||||||
| *** | significant at p<.01 | ||||||