Table 14. Logistic Regression Analysis of Supreme Court Decisions on First Amendment Cases, 1954-1988
(Only Justices Who Participated in Brandenburg)
               
Predictor   Before and After Brandenburg Before Brandenburg Only After Brandenburg Only
               
Attitudes of Justices   -1.90 *** -1.49 ** -3.91 ***
    (0.53)   (0.70)   (1.20)  
Brandenburg   -2.36 ***        
    (0.60)          
Political Speech   -2.63 ***     8.49
    (0.83)       (53.86)  
DOCTRINE              
  Likely and Imminent Risk of Lawless Action 1.31 * -7.22   -12.59  
    (0.75)   (27.34)   (336.65)  
  Not an Issue -0.39   0.01   -10.92  
    (0.49)   (0.56)   (299.66)  
SETTING              
  Public forum -0.64   -9.17   -6.82  
    (0.90)   (27.36)   (199.20)  
  Semi-public forum 0.77   1.23   3.69  
    (0.93)   (1.41)   (2.82)  
  Not an Issue 0.78   0.73   2.72  
    (1.02)   (1.58)   (2.24)  
GOVERNMENT              
  Federal 0.91   -9.95   2.75
    (0.74)   (27.33)   (191.78)  
  State -0.76   -9.92   12.64
    (0.62)   (27.35)   (199.22)  
  School or University -2.62 ** -19.73   [no cases]
    (1.26)   (54.64)      
  No Government 2.06 ** 1.94 * [no cases]
    (0.89)   (1.02)    
SPEAKER              
  Communist -1.88 ** -9.42   19.79
    (0.78)   (27.32)   (107.76)  
  Racial Minority -1.99 *** -9.67   -0.40
    (0.68)   (27.31)   (1.75)  
  Other -0.82   -17.74   22.31
    (0.78)   (48.41)   (107.76)  
Constant   5.10 *** 18.48   -12.58  
    (1.62)   (54.63)   (373.95)  
               
Chi square 76.76 *** 55.14 *** 48.48 ***
    (15 d.f.)   (13 d.f.)   (12 d.f.)  
R-squared 0.25   0.26   0.55  
% Correctly Predicted 80.78   78.05   92.31  
% Reduction in Error 35.80   38.99   58.83  
  N 255   164   91  
Chow Test Chi Square     57.41***
    (13 d.f.)
               
* significant at p<.10            
** significant at p<..05            
*** significant at p<.01            

Last Updated on 4/12/1998
By Bert Kritzer