Table 13. Logistic Regression Analysis of Supreme Court Decisions on First Amendment Cases, 1954-1988
               
Predictor   Before and After Brandenburg Before Brandenburg Only After Brandenburg Only
               
Attitudes of Justices   -1.91 *** -2.13 *** -2.31 ***
    (0.27)   (0.48)   (0.42)  
Brandenburg   -2.23 ***        
    (0.45)          
Political Speech   -1.69 **     1.53 *
    (0.55)       (0.86)  
DOCTRINE              
  Likely and Imminent Risk of Lawless Action 2.22 *** -5.81   5.38  
    (0.59)   (13.85)   (20.06)  
  Not an Issue 0.32   0.50   6.49  
    (0.36)   (0.43)   (20.01)  
SETTING              
  Public forum 0.16   -7.46   0.26  
    (0.66)   (13.88)   (1.47)  
  Semi-public forum 0.83   1.34   0.00  
    (0.69)   (1.09)   (1.47)  
  Not an Issue 0.42   0.37   0.98  
    (0.74)   (1.23)   (1.25)  
GOVERNMENT              
  Federal 0.35   -8.22   2.82 ***
    (0.46)   (13.84)   (1.08)  
  State -0.40   -8.99   5.45 ***
    (0.44)   (13.85)   (1.94)  
  School or University -2.14 ** -17.91   [no cases]
    (1.07)   (27.64)      
  No Government 0.70   1.15   [no cases]
    (0.66)   (0.83)    
SPEAKER              
  Communist -1.68 *** -8.44   5.24 **
    (0.63)   (13.83)   (2.12)  
  Racial Minority -1.70 *** -8.85   3.23 *
    (0.50)   (13.80)   (1.75)  
  Other -0.73   -10.34   5.54 ***
    (0.57)   (13.85)   (1.86)  
Constant   2.60 ** 16.10   -14.43  
    (1.02)   (27.63)   (20.18)  
               
Chi square 132.80 *** 83.92 *** 106.47 ***
    (15 d.f.)   (13 d.f.)   (12 d.f.)  
R-squared 0.24   0.25   0.49  
% Correctly Predicted 76.01   75.78   83.64  
% Reduction in Error 34.85   34.73   55.01  
  N 421   256   165  
Chow Test Chi Square     87.98***
    (13 d.f.)
               
* significant at p<.10            
** significant at p<..05            
*** significant at p<.01            

Last Updated on 4/12/1998
By Bert Kritzer